Homework: Too much, too little, just right?

Homework. My son refuses to do his, and my daughter is a perfectionist about it. She started working on her book report before it was even officially assigned! Four weeks before it was due, she was already worried that she wouldn’t have enough time to finish it.
She definitely has my husband’s genes when it comes to school work. He started getting stomachaches in third grade, he was so anxious to please his teacher. That was about the time that I decided I didn’t need to do homework – I was good at spelling, reading and writing, and what did I need math for anyway?
I managed to muddle my way through many years of schooling with this attitude, finally capitulating in high school, when I realized that, yeah, maybe I didn’t know everything, or even enough. It wasn’t until graduate school, however, that I really gained the discipline to be a good student, to manage my time and meet deadlines on assignments.
My daughter is learning these skills at a much earlier age than I, and I think it will serve her well. She’s only in fifth grade, but already she’s willing to spend an hour or more each afternoon on her homework. Her book report is due today, and not only is it well-written, it looks beautiful too.
Given my own history with homework, I know I’m in no position to question how much work the teacher is assigning, but I have to wonder, are we expecting too much of our kids? Should my 10-year-old really be spending an hour every night on homework? At this rate, I can only imagine what the work load will be like when she gets to high school.
What are your thoughts? What’s the purpose of homework? And how much is reasonable – and useful – to expect from our kids?
Posted by Anne





1 Comment so far

  1. Angela11:00 am on October 21, 2008

    I could go on and on about this for days! I will say that every child is different, and that is true in every respect- including homework. I have a Homework Personality Quiz that I tell parents to take to get them thinking about the best way to support each child’s learning, studying and homework style.

    http://www.family-homework-answers.com/homework-solutions.html

    Studies and common sense show that so much of homework is a waste of time. Not only does it not help students retain knowledge, it turns them off from learning, reading and studying. Millions of families spend evenings, holidays and weekends arguing and fighting over homework when they could be spending time together or (gasp!) relaxing. If more good, thoughtful, sensible homework was assigned instead of busy work- this kind of decision would not be necessary.

Leave a comment

Name (required)

Email (required)

Website

You can use these tags in your comments: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Add your comment